#22:
October CountryThis documentary chronicles the life of four generations of a working class family in Mohawk Valley of upstate New York. It is a family that seems trapped in economic insecurity, serial attachments to abusive men, unintended pregnancies, and relationships that force the viewer to ask what is the meaning of masculinity and femininity is a world that looks like an endless wrap party for the
Steve Wilkos Show only without any yelling or crying.
The recurring theme that brings together the film, which follows the family from one Halloween to the next, is the persistence of ghosts. Between the patriarch's sister, a self proclaimed witch who hobbles around the local cemetery asking to communicate with the ghosts who presumably live there, to the whole array of family dysfunction that infiltrates the lives of the people in the film, each generation is haunted by the bad decisions of the generation before. The people look clear-eyed at these decisions, even as they replicate them, seemingly unable to break the pattern. The effect is not so much learned helplessness as daytime TV confessional and a disturbing disconnect between how they describe their conditions and how they respond to them. It seems to occur to none of them before the fact that they have options. It is tempting to say that they don't but that is clearly not true. Granted, their options may be unconscionably limited but they are options.
The emotional center of the family is the mother, the director's own mother, for whom family is the most important thing and who provides unconditional love from the middle of the chaos that surrounds her. Offering level-headed, if sometimes seemingly callous, advice to her daughter and granddaughters she seems to know what the future holds but, like them, is powerless to alter it in any meaningful way. She exhibits no sentimentality about the state of her family but also withholds no support or love, even for the foster child who spends his days stoned in the basement and is ultimately incarcerated for stealing from her. When he gets out, she is there to take him to Wal-Mart to buy new clothes and to admire the authenticity his Halloween costume, an abused woman, complete with black eye.
The trajectory is relentlessly down.
Each woman in this film has made disastrous choices in men, men who molest their daughters, beat them, dominate them. For what it is worth, most of these men are themselves family ghosts--long gone or at least absent. The men who are around seem to be grasping for a sense of their own identity as men in stereotypical notions of breadwinning and control, neither of which they can manage given the circumstances of their lives. This seems to be the primary inheritance passed between generations of women.
The only potential exception to this rule is the second daughter of the second generation, eleven year old Desi, who sees her way out. She's spunky, smart, and perceptive but her vision is distressingly narrow. Her plan to break the cycle of abuse and neglect is to graduate from high school.
These people talk like people who have been exposed to a lot of Dr. Phil and the family has all of the marks of the beaten down blue collar scrim: obesity, lots of plastic tchotchkes functioning as decor, Mt. Dew for breakfast. The POV is not judgmental--these folks spend plenty of time judging themselves--and it is not overtly critical. What it is is resigned.
In the end, the director's off-camera voice asks each person if he or she believes in ghosts. The father, a Vietnam veteran who carries around a lot of resentment about being sent away before he could grow up, answers that they are all in your head but that "a lot of times what's in your head is physical." But his wife, given the circumstances of her life, has the most perceptive answer. "I'm more afraid of the living than the dead."